Champagne Sunset Sail on Selina II — Romantic Shelter Island Heights Cruise
Toast the sunset aboard Selina II: a two-hour private wooden-yacht sail across Shelter Island’s calm Peconic Bay, ideal for proposals, anniversaries, or an intimate evening with bubbly and golden-hour light.
Book with Sail Selina NY
Choose a date and book.
Field Guide
A closer look at the experience.
Toast the sunset aboard Selina II: a two-hour private wooden-yacht sail across Shelter Island’s calm Peconic Bay, ideal for proposals, anniversaries, or an intimate evening with bubbly and golden-hour light.
Written by The Adventure Collective
On an evening when the Peconic Bay mirrors the sky, the Selina II slips away from the docks for a two-hour Champagne Sunset Sail out of Shelter Island Heights, New York. This private wooden yacht experience pairs classic boat-handling with the slow unfolding of Long Island’s western soundscapes. The setting is specific: sheltered channels between Shelter Island and the North Fork, where salt marshes, eelgrass flats, and low glacial bluffs stage a changing light show that turns perfectly with the sun. Host to up to six guests, the Selina II feels like a borrowed memory of old-school yachting—bright varnish, brass fittings, and the wooden thrum underfoot. Guests can choose to be hands-on, learning to raise canvas and trim sheets, or to lean back with a glass of bubbly and a curated playlist via Bluetooth. The experience is framed for two hours to hit the golden hour, when the bay’s shallow sandbars and the distant South Fork silhouette come into crisp relief. What makes this sail a standout is scale and intimacy: small group size, a historic hull, and routes that take advantage of Shelter Island’s calm coves. Unlike busier ferry corridors, these waters reveal oyster beds and marsh birds, with occasional glances at private waterfront estates that tell a quiet local story of maritime life. Geologically the shoreline reflects the last glacial retreat—a low-lying coast of outwash plains and sheltered coves rather than sheer cliffs—so the navigation emphasizes breadth of view over dramatic elevation. For couples this is an efficient, low-effort way to feel transported: bring a favorite North Fork wine, add a charcuterie board or chilled bubbly from the onboard options, and let the captain handle the tide reads. Practical notes: specific check-in details and the exact dock are provided by the operator at booking; the meeting point is not listed here. The trip runs two hours and is suitable for guests seeking a relaxed, scenic cruise rather than an athletic sail. Shelter Island Heights itself acts as a quiet gateway between Long Island’s two forks, historically a summer retreat and now a place where maritime traditions persist. The Selina II adds to that heritage by offering a wooden-boat experience that’s rare in the region— a curated, private window onto Peconic Bay’s soft, coastal landscapes at sunset. Optional add-ons make the evening flexible: charcuterie boards, premium flowers, chilled bubbly, and a professional photographer are available through the operator, letting you tailor the cruise for proposals or anniversaries. Evenings can be breezy — bring a light layer — and the crew will brief guests on safety and motion considerations before departure. Book early for weekend summer slots; the small six-guest limit fills quickly during peak season and at holiday weekends.
Plan your trip
Things to know before you go.
Suitable for most adults; ability to step aboard a small boarding ladder and move on deck recommended
Bring layers
Evenings on the water cool quickly—pack a windproof layer and a light sweater, even in summer.
BYOB local wine
You may bring your favorite North Fork wine or choose an onboard chilled bottle for toasting.
Shoes with grip
Wear non-marking, slip-resistant shoes to move safely on a wooden deck.
Book weekends early
Small six-guest capacity fills up during summer weekends and holidays—reserve well in advance.
What to bring
- Windproof jacket (essential) — Protects against cool breezes during sunset passages.
- Non-slip deck shoes (essential) — Keeps footing secure on wooden decks and when boarding.
- Sunglasses with strap — Reduces glare off the bay and prevents lost shades overboard.
- Compact camera or phone (essential) — Capture golden-hour reflections and rigging details.
Beyond the itinerary
A little local perspective.
Shelter Island sits between Long Island’s North and South Forks and has long been a seasonal haven; maritime traditions persist in small-boat culture and historic homesteads.
Places to keep an eye out for
- Mashomack Preserve boardwalks and shoreline views
- Sylvester Manor Historic Homestead and grounds
Wildlife notes
- Osprey
- Great blue heron
Peconic Bay supports eelgrass beds and shellfish; avoid anchoring on seagrass, respect wildlife, and carry out all waste to limit impacts.
Your questions, answered.
Where do I check in for the sail?
Specific check-in details and the exact dock are supplied by the operator after booking; the meeting point is not listed in this summary.
Can we bring our own wine or champagne?
Yes. BYOB is allowed; the operator also offers chilled bottles and bubbly as an add-on.
Is this activity kid- or pet-friendly?
Group size and vessel setup are best suited to adult guests; inquire with the operator about children or pets when booking.
What happens if the weather is bad?
Operators typically contact guests about cancellations or rescheduling due to unsafe weather; policies are provided at booking.
Can guests participate in sailing the boat?
Yes. Guests are welcome to be hands-on with raising sails and trimming sheets under crew guidance.
Is there seating and restrooms onboard?
The Selina II is a classic wooden yacht with deck seating; restroom availability should be confirmed with the operator prior to departure.
More experiences with Sail Selina NY
Verified experiences and guided adventures in the surrounding area.
