Rising steadily from the well-worn paths of Yosemite Valley’s northern flank, Commissioner Buttress invites climbers seeking a hands-on trad adventure away from the typical crowds flocking to nearby favorites. This route offers nearly 450 feet spread across five pitches that quietly combine varied crack systems, exposed ledges, and moderate technical challenges—an old-school climb that remains a hidden gem amid Yosemite’s granite giants.

Beginning with a deceptively mellow low-angle groove, the first pitch soon insists on steady effort as the terrain steepens into a committed dihedral. Here, the rock demands precise jams and fingerwork, especially near the crux where irregular cracks test your gear placements and flexibility. While a 4.5-inch cam proves useful, vigilant route reading offers alternative stances for smaller protection. After surmounting the corner, climbers reach a belay perched atop an exposed granite blade, complete with rap slings and a piton—a reminder of this route’s heritage.

Pitch two veers left after the belay, challenging you to resist the impulse to take the more direct but risky line under the roof. Instead, a careful chimney ascend leads into steep double cracks guarding an imposing roof. A 4.5-inch cam is again a valuable asset here, and most opt to use the sturdy tree overhead to negotiate the roof’s lip. Beyond, the route offers a choice—either chimneying left or staying exposed on the face with sustained crack climbing. A large ledge populated by manzanita bushes marks the pitch's end, a perfect spot to catch your breath and savor the quiet aside from Yosemite’s bustle.

Pitch three is a shorter but satisfying scramble capped by a narrow chimney behind a large flake, leading to another sprawling ledge system. It’s an inviting chance to reset after the more technical climbing below.

The fourth pitch trades a defined crack for a wandering ascent up a low angle face—here there's scarce protection, demanding careful route finding and patience. Pro tends to cluster near a flake about 30 feet above the start, providing tighter securements before a final traverse on steeper rock leads to another ledge.

Finally, the fifth pitch arcs around the corner into a low-angle gully where the climbing mellows into mostly fourth-class scrambling, punctuated by a short but awkward fifth-class move near the top. This final push finishes just below the summit of Manure Pile Buttress.

Descend by heading north and west from the top, skirting a drop-off that blocks direct access down to Nutcracker. This route leads eventually into a gully connecting with the well-used Manure Pile descent trail, offering a safe and familiar exit.

With protection ranging up to 4.5 inches and doubles of smaller sizes recommended, Commissioner Buttress is approachable yet rewarding for climbers who appreciate hands-on crack climbing with a bit of old-school flavor. Unlike the jam-packed After Six or Nutcracker routes, this climb usually offers solitude and uninterrupted flow.

Ideal for those wanting to explore a quieter side of Yosemite's iconic valley walls, Commissioner Buttress marries moderate difficulty with sustained movement and natural exposure. Prepare for the effort with sturdy shoes, a good rack for crack protection, and enough water for the approach and descent. Timing your climb early in the day can help avoid midday heat and maximize comfort on the sunny granite.

This classic line, though somewhat overshadowed by more famous neighbors, holds a special appeal for those eager to step off the beaten path without sacrificing technical climbing or memorable terrain. Commissioner Buttress reminds us that some of the finest adventures come from routes just a short hike beyond the crowds.